How to Revise a Novel After the First Draft: A 7 Step Guide
You've just typed "the end". The manuscript exists, which is already more than most people who start a novel ever manage. Now comes the part that decides whether that text becomes a book: revision.
How do you revise a novel? Let the first draft rest for a few weeks, then reread it in full and revise in layers, from big to small: structure and plot first, then characters and point of view, then individual scenes, and finally sentences, rhythm and typos. Fixing commas in a chapter you'll later cut is the fastest way to waste months.
Key takeaways
- Let your first draft rest for two to six weeks before rereading it.
- Revise by layer: structure, characters, scenes, sentences. One layer per pass.
- Before changing anything, do one full read and only take notes.
- Cut: the second draft is usually shorter than the first.
- Finish with beta readers, then proofreading.
Why the first draft isn't the novel
The first draft is for discovering the story; revision is for telling it. They're two different jobs that need two different mindsets: while you write you have to believe in it, while you revise you have to doubt everything.
Even famous authors work this way. Ernest Hemingway told The Paris Review he rewrote the last page of A Farewell to Arms thirty-nine times before he was satisfied (The Paris Review, "The Art of Fiction No. 21", 1958). In 2012 his grandson Seán Hemingway said he had found 47 alternative endings among his papers, many of them published in a new edition of the novel (NPR, 2012). That isn't perfectionism. It's the method.
So if your first draft looks rough, that's fine. It's raw material, and revision is where you shape it.
Step 1: let the manuscript rest
Before you reread, put the text away. Distance lets you read it as a reader, not as the author who already knows what they meant to say.
In On Writing (2000), Stephen King advises leaving the manuscript in a drawer for a minimum of six weeks before the second draft (Nat Eliason's notes on On Writing). If you have a deadline, even two weeks makes a difference. Meanwhile, write something else: a short story, notes for your next project, or your novel synopsis, which forces you to look at the story from above anyway.
If you've just finished the November challenge with the 50,000 word plan, this is the right time to stop: December to rest, January to revise.
Step 2: the full read, without editing
Do the first reread in one go, over a few days, without changing the text. The goal is to see the whole novel the way a reader will.
A few tricks help:
- Change the format. Read on another device, in another font, or print it out. The text will feel less like yours.
- Annotate, don't rewrite. Mark in the margin where you get bored, where you're confused, where a character acts for no reason, where one scene repeats another.
- Write one line per chapter. At the end you'll have a map of the novel as it actually is, not as you thought it was.
That map is the most useful tool of the whole revision: it shows gaps, repetitions and chapters that don't move anything forward.
Step 3: structural revision
The first layer is the story as a whole. This is where the biggest changes happen, the ones that move, merge or delete entire chapters.
Ask yourself these questions, one at a time:
- What is the novel's central question? It should be clear by the end of the first act and answered in the ending.
- Does every chapter change something? If the story holds up just as well without it, it's a candidate for cutting.
- Does the pacing hold? Look for stretches where nothing important happens for many pages, often in the middle.
- Does it start in the right place? Many first drafts start too early. Reread the guide on how to write the opening of a novel and ask whether the novel really begins in chapter one or in chapter three.
- Does the ending keep the promise of the beginning? The tone and the opening question should come back at the end.
Fix these problems before anything else. If the way you organized your novel included an outline, compare it with the map from Step 2: the gap between the two tells you where the story took another road, and whether that road is better.
Step 4: characters and point of view
The second layer is about who lives the story. An inconsistent character breaks the reader's trust more than a plot error does.
Check these points:
- Motivation. Every major choice a character makes needs a reason the reader can reconstruct.
- Arc. Is the protagonist different at the end than at the start? Different in what, exactly?
- Consistent details. Age, appearance, relationships, places. In a long novel, green eyes in chapter 3 easily turn brown by chapter 20: a sheet for every character avoids that.
- Point of view. Make sure you don't slip into one character's head when the scene is told by another. If you're unsure about your choice, the article on point of view shows what changes.
- Distinct voices. Cover the speaker's name: can you still tell who's talking? If not, revisit your dialogue.
Step 5: scene revision
The third layer goes down to the single scene. Every scene should have a goal, an obstacle and an outcome that changes the situation.
For each one, ask:
- Who wants what, and what's stopping them?
- Do I enter the scene as late as possible and leave as early as possible?
- Is there a passage that tells what I could show, or the other way round? This is where show, don't tell helps, applied with judgment.
- Do the descriptions serve the story or slow it down?
This is also the moment to cut. Stephen King sums up the rule as: second draft equals first draft minus 10 percent (notes on On Writing). If you're wondering whether the novel is the right length for its genre, compare your count with the ranges in the guide on how many words a novel should have.
Step 6: line editing
Only now is it worth working on the language, when you know the scenes you're polishing will stay in the book.
What to look for:
- Repetition. Words that come back within a few lines, personal tics ("suddenly", "somehow", "seemed").
- Too many adverbs and adjectives. A more precise verb often makes them unnecessary.
- Rhythm. Read the most important pages aloud. Where you stumble, the reader will stumble. The article on sentence rhythm explains how punctuation guides reading.
- Dialogue tags. "Said" almost always works better than elaborate verbs.
Work one chapter at a time and don't go back to structure unless you find a serious problem. Mixing layers is the main reason revisions never end.
Step 7: beta readers, then proofreading
When the text feels ready, let other people read it. Two or three beta readers are enough, as long as they read your genre and are willing to tell you where they got bored.
Ask for specific feedback: where did you stop reading? Which character didn't convince you? What did you expect to happen? If several readers flag the same spot, the problem is real, even if the fix they suggest isn't.
After the last round of changes comes proofreading: typos, punctuation, consistent spelling and capitalization. It's the last step, not the first. Then the manuscript is ready for standard manuscript format and for submission to a publisher.
The most common revision mistakes
- Editing while writing the first draft. It slows you down and often stops you: revision comes after.
- Starting with the commas. Polishing sentences that will be cut is wasted time.
- Revising everything in a single pass. Your mind can't check plot and typos at the same time.
- Not saving versions. Keep every draft: sometimes a cut scene comes in handy.
- Revising forever. Set a number of passes or a date. A novel is never perfect, but at some point it's finished.
How GrinTale helps with revision
A manuscript split into chapters and scenes is far easier to revise than a single 300 page file. In GrinTale you can move chapters and scenes, keep character and location sheets next to the text, and check your word count as you cut. If your first draft lives in Google Docs, you can import it chapter by chapter and start your structural revision with the novel's map already in place.
Frequently asked questions
How many revisions does a novel need?
There's no fixed number. Many authors do at least three main passes (structure, scenes, sentences) plus a final proofread. Revising one layer at a time matters more than the total number of passes.
How long should the first draft rest?
Stephen King suggests a minimum of six weeks. If you're in a hurry, even two or three weeks give you enough distance to read the text with fresh eyes.
Should I revise on paper or on screen?
For the full read in Step 2, paper, or at least a format different from the one you wrote in, helps you notice things you miss on screen. For structural changes, a digital tool is better, since it lets you move chapters and scenes around.
When should I let others read the manuscript?
After you've solved the structural and character problems yourself. If you share it too early, readers will point out things you already know and you'll use up their attention.
Do I need to pay a professional editor?
It isn't required to submit a manuscript to a publisher. It can be worth it if you plan to self-publish or if, after beta readers, you know something isn't working but can't figure out what.
Pronto a scrivere il tuo prossimo capolavoro?
7 days free, then €49/year. Cancel within 7 days and you pay nothing.